ICHRA vs. HRA

Key takeaways 

• ICHRA allows businesses to reimburse employees for individual health insurance premiums and qualified medical expenses, offering more flexibility and choice. 
• Traditional HRAs are tied to group health plans, reimbursing employees for medical costs without individual plan selection. 
• Choosing between ICHRA and HRA depends on your budget, workforce needs, and whether flexibility or a group-based approach better aligns with your goals. 

Health Reimbursement Arrangements (HRAs) are employer-funded benefits that reimburse employees for eligible medical expenses. Individual Coverage HRAs (ICHRAs) stand out as they reimburse employees for individual health insurance plans, providing greater flexibility compared to traditional HRAs tied to group health plans. This article explores the distinctions and benefits of each option to help businesses make informed decisions. 

Employers must evaluate their workforce needs, regulatory requirements, and financial goals to decide which arrangement best suits their business. 

What are HRAs? 

HRAs are employer-funded accounts that reimburse employees for eligible medical expenses and insurance premiums. These tax-advantaged benefits offer employers flexibility in designing healthcare support for their workforce. 

Types of HRAs: 

• Group Coverage HRA (GCHRA): Supplements group plans by covering out-of-pocket costs. 

• Qualified Small Employer HRA (QSEHRA): Tailored for businesses with fewer than 50 employees. 

• Individual Coverage HRA (ICHRA): Allows reimbursement for individual insurance premiums. 

• Integrated HRA: Complements high-deductible health plans to cover additional expenses. 

What Is an ICHRA? 

An ICHRA reimburses employees tax-free for individual health insurance premiums and medical expenses. Unlike traditional HRAs, ICHRAs are ACA-compliant and cater to diverse employee needs, including part-time and remote staff. 

Employers can customize contributions based on employee classes, such as full-time or part-time roles, making ICHRAs a flexible solution that aligns with organizational goals. 

Key similarities between ICHRA and HRA 

ICHRA and traditional HRAs share several important features: 

• Tax-advantaged reimbursements: Both options allow employers to reimburse employees for eligible medical expenses and insurance premiums on a tax-free basis. 

• Flexibility for employers: Employers have the freedom to design benefit structures tailored to their workforce, including setting reimbursement limits. 

• No pre-funding required: Unlike other benefit options, neither ICHRA nor HRA requires employers to pre-fund accounts; reimbursements are only made when employees submit eligible claims. 

• Employer-sponsored plans: Both are employer-funded benefits, providing a practical and customizable way to support employees’ healthcare needs. 

Key differences between ICHRA and Traditional HRA 

The table below outlines the key differences between ICHRA and traditional HRAs, making it easier for employers to decide which option best fits their workforce and benefits goals. 

Key differences	ICHRA	Traditional HRA
Coverage options	Allows employees to purchase individual health insurance plans from the market.	Linked to employer-sponsored group health plans.
Contribution structure	Employers can customize contributions for specific employee classes (e.g., full-time, part-time, remote).	Follows a standardized structure tied to group health plans.
ACA compliance	Meets ACA employer mandate requirements for applicable large employers (ALEs).	Does not independently fulfill ACA compliance requirements.
Portability	Employees can retain individual health plans if they change jobs.	Tied to group health plans, limiting portability and employee flexibility.

Advantages of ICHRA over Traditional HRAs 

ICHRA offers several unique benefits that make it a flexible and attractive option for employers: 

• Employees can choose their own health insurance policy rather than relying on a single employer-selected plan, offering more personalized coverage. 

• Coverage is portable, meaning employees can keep their individual health insurance policy even if they leave the organization, as it is not tied to their job. 

• Employers can tailor benefits and allowance amounts for different groups of employees based on criteria like job role, age, or family status, ensuring the benefit aligns with organizational needs. 

• Unlike other HRAs, there are no minimum or maximum employer contribution limits, allowing employers to offer as much or as little as they prefer. 

• ICHRA has no participation requirements, meaning there’s no minimum number of employees needed to offer the benefit. 

These features make ICHRA a flexible, ACA-compliant option that enhances employee satisfaction and provides greater adaptability for remote and part-time staff. 

Benefits of HRAs for employers 

• Cost control and predictability: Employers set fixed reimbursement allowances, ensuring predictable healthcare costs without the risk of fluctuating premiums. 

• Tax benefits: Reimbursements are tax-free for both employers and employees, reducing overall benefit costs. 

• Attract and retain talent: Offering HRAs demonstrates a commitment to employee health, making it easier to attract and retain top talent. 

• Simplified administration: Compared to traditional group insurance plans, HRAs streamline administration by focusing on reimbursements rather than managing insurance policies directly. 

Challenges and considerations for employers 

• Complexity of setup and administration: Setting up an HRA requires careful planning to define allowances, eligible expenses, and employee classes, along with managing reimbursements and documentation. 

• Communicating benefits clearly: Employees may not fully understand how HRAs work. Clear communication and education are crucial to ensure employees maximize their benefits and understand their value. 

• Regulatory compliance: Employers must stay compliant with IRS rules, HIPAA regulations, and ACA requirements, as well as monitor potential changes to healthcare laws that could impact HRA administration. 

Which option is right for your business? 

Choosing between ICHRA and traditional HRAs depends on several key factors: 

• Employee demographics: Consider your workforce’s needs, such as whether they prefer individual plan flexibility (ICHRA) or group plan coverage (traditional HRA). Remote, part-time, or diverse employee groups may benefit more from ICHRA’s customization. 

• Business size and industry: Larger employers or those in industries with high employee turnover may find ICHRA’s portability more appealing, while businesses with stable, localized workforces may prefer traditional HRAs. 

• Budgetary constraints: Assess your financial capacity. ICHRA’s lack of contribution limits allows for flexibility, while traditional HRAs may offer more predictable costs tied to group health plans. 

• Long-term goals for employee benefits: Determine whether your priority is offering flexible, portable benefits (ICHRA) or enhancing group health plan support (traditional HRA) to align with your company’s values and recruitment goals. 

Bringing it all together 

HRAs, including ICHRAs, offer employers flexible, tax-advantaged ways to support employee healthcare. While both share similarities like tax-free reimbursements and employer-sponsored structures, their differences — such as ICHRA’s flexibility and portability versus traditional HRAs’ alignment with group health plans — make them suited to different needs. 

Employers should assess factors like workforce demographics, budget, and long-term goals to determine the best option. By understanding these tools, businesses can make informed decisions that benefit both their employees and their bottom line. 

2814-2025